Finst

Kalshi Fights New York and Threatens to Shut Down

After being sent back to state court, pressure on Kalshi is rising: New York sees event contracts as gambling, while the CFTC is pushing for nationwide coverage.

Kalshi Fights New York and Threatens to Shut Down

Key Takeaways

  • A federal judge sent Kalshi’s case in New York back to state court.
  • New York sees prediction markets as gambling and wants Kalshi to stop its event contracts.
  • Kalshi warns that a ban in New York could cripple the company nationwide.

Kalshi is in serious legal trouble after a federal judge sent the case in New York back to state court. That puts the prediction market back in front of state authorities who want the platform to stop offering its event contracts.

Battle Over Oversight

New York says prediction markets like Kalshi are basically gambling and therefore fall under the state’s own gambling laws. The state had already tried to shut the company down earlier, but that case was then moved to federal court. Now the court in the Southern District of New York has ruled that the state court is the right place to keep handling the dispute.

That is especially sensitive for Kalshi because the company is based in New York. The company warned that a ban in its home state would put it in an impossible position, especially since the Commodity Futures Trading Commission has told the platform to keep operating nationwide without state-by-state restrictions.

New Pressure From the State

On Friday, an assistant attorney general from New York filed a request for a temporary restraining order. According to a CFTC letter in federal court, a shutdown in New York could force Kalshi to halt all of its operations because the company runs from that state. A federal judge later denied that request on Friday, according to attorney Daniel Wallach.

Kalshi responded that under the Biden administration it was certified as a federally regulated exchange and has complied with the rules from day one. The company also said it wants to talk with Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James about a solution that protects the interests of the 1.2 million New Yorkers who use Kalshi.

Why This Matters More Broadly

The case matters for crypto readers in Europe because it shows how sharp the line between federal and local rules can be when it comes to new trading products. Kalshi has long been at the center of the national debate over prediction markets in the US, and this week a third federal court also ruled against the company. With those conflicting rulings, the odds are growing that the US Supreme Court will eventually have to decide how much room states have to regulate these markets.

The legal pressure fits into a broader string of setbacks for the platform. In an earlier case, Kalshi already took a court hit in Maryland, where a court ruled that the state could go after the company under its own gambling rules.


Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. The information provided may be incomplete, inaccurate, or outdated and should not be relied upon as such. Nothing on this website should be considered a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any cryptocurrency. Investing in crypto-assets involves risk of loss.